95.3 / 88.5 FM Grand Rapids and 95.3 FM Muskegon
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Grand Rapids approves clinic noise ordinance, sparking free speech debate

Sign in front of Planned Parenthood in Grand Rapids
WGVU Photo
Sign in front of Planned Parenthood in Grand Rapids

Anti-abortion protestors say the new noise ordinance that prohibits amplified sound around medical clinics violates their right to free speech. Supporters say it protects patients and restores peace and quiet

“It violates the law of God.”

During public comment Josh and others told the city commission they oppose the new noise ordinance around health care clinics for religious reasons.
“God has said you shall not murder. This facility this is designed to protect is committing mass murder by abortion.”

But commissioners approved the ordinance prohibiting the use of microphones and amplified sound within 100 feet of a health care clinic. Interim city attorney Phil Strom says amplified sound is not protected speech.

“There is no constitutional right to use amplified sound.”

But commissioner Kelsey Perdue is concerned the ordinance could suppress amplified protests on other issues throughout the city.

“How much of downtown will be excluded if we go through with this ordinance? We have health facilities everywhere.  It’s 100 feet from each building, each property line. That can get really confusing for protestors.”

Mayor David LaGrand thinks the limits on amplified sound won’t restrict free speech and answers complaints about noise.

“I am convinced this will address concerns about rights to peace and quiet around those health care facilities.”

——
For a weekly dose of news right to your inbox, sign up for the WGVU newsletter.

Related Content