95.3 / 88.5 FM Grand Rapids and 95.3 FM Muskegon
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Flint water defendants take case to Michigan Supreme Court

The Flint Water Plant water tower in Flint, Mich.
Carlos Osorio
The Flint Water Plant water tower in Flint, Mich.

Charges against defendants going all the way up to ex-Governor Rick Snyder could be thrown out

The Michigan Supreme Court heard oral arguments today on whether defendants in the Flint water criminal case were denied a key constitutional right. If they win, charges against defendants going all the way up to ex-Governor Rick Snyder could be thrown out.

The specific issue before the court is whether three of the defendants were denied their right to a preliminary hearing. The preliminary hearing is where prosecutors have to show a judge they have enough evidence to take a case to trial. But the government says that step’s been covered because these charges were brought in this unique process where a judge acts as both prosecutor and grand jury.

The state’s lawyers focused on the argument that even if it’s unusual, the law allows for a one-judge grand jury to decide whether to charge or not to charge.

This is Assistant Attorney General Christopher Kessel. He says the Flint water case is an unusual situation.

“…where the allegations of government corruption at the highest level do result in the victimization of an entire city. Now, I appreciate that defendants want to have a preliminary exam, but defendants are not entitled to choose their right of prosecution.”

The defendants are former state Health and Human Services Director Nick Lyon, who is charged with involuntary manslaughter. Former state health official Nancy Peeler is charged with misconduct in office and willful neglect of duty. Richard Baird, a top advisor to then-Governor Rick Snyder faces charges of misconduct, perjury, and extortion.
Defense counsel Harold Gurewitz represents Nancy Peeler. He said the preliminary examination protects defendants’ rights.

“That includes the right to confront witnesses, to review discovery, and to understand the theory of the government’s case so that can be challenged.”

One justice, Elizabeth Clement, recused herself from the case because she worked with some of the defendants as then-Governor Rick Snyder’s legal counsel.
The remaining six justices had a lot of pointed questions. Most of them were aimed at the state’s arguments and why allowing a single person to act in multiple roles behind closed doors was appropriate.

“In a preliminary exam, the defendant gets to see and hear the evidence and challenge it. Isn’t that an important difference?”

That’s Chief Justice Bridget Mary McCormack.

“A citizens grand jury stands between the accused and the government. Our fellow citizens get to stand between us and the government. Here you have the government standing between the accused and the government? There are important differences”

The response was, again, the government gets to decide which legal mechanism to use to determine whether charges can be brought.

Former Governor Rick Snyder was not in the room and is not a named defendant in the cases argued before the court. But there are stakes for him in this decision because he also faces criminal charges related to the Flint water crisis. He faces two counts of willful neglect of duty. All told, nine people have been charged and all have an interest in what the Supreme Court decides.
John Bursch represents Nicholas Lyon. He called combining the power of a judge and a prosecutor into one office to consider and issue charges “uniquely unconstitutional.”

“Because it’s the judge who’s hearing the evidence and issuing the indictment that the prosecutor is supposed to be issuing.”

And, if Bursch gets his way, he says it’s possible all the charges against all nine Flint defendants would be dropped.

“So if the court agrees with us, then every single one of these cases has to be thrown out.”

If that happens, the attorney general’s office would face a decision on whether to start over and file new criminal charges in the Flint water case or give up. The Supreme Court’s current term ends in July.

Related Content
  • Michigan residents were not responsible for the overpayments and will not be required to pay them back.
  • U.S. officials confirm the FBI is investigating whether Ahmad Chalabi told Iranian agents that the United States had broken their country's communications code. Chalabi, a formerly exiled Iraqi leader now back in Baghdad, provided the United States with details, now discredited, about Saddam Hussein's weapons program. NPR's Mary Louise Kelly reports.
  • A controversial federal ban on a type of abortion procedure has been struck down by a federal judge in San Francisco. The "Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act," signed into law by President Bush last November, was declared to be unconstitutional and an infringement on a woman's right to choose. Hear NPR's Melissa Block and NPR's Richard Gonzales.
  • Iraq's new interim government is announced, with Sunni leader Ghazi al-Yawer named as the country's president. Al-Yawer was previously a member of the U.S.-appointed Governing Council, which dissolved itself after the choices were made final. The new leadership, to take power on June 30, was chosen by U.N. envoy Lakhdar Brahimi in consultation with the council. NPR's Emily Harris reports.
  • The military judge in the cases of three soldiers accused of abusing prisoner at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison will allow the defense to interview U.S. Central Command head Gen. John Abizaid and Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, the ranking general in Iraq. Col. James Pohl made his rulings during pre-trial motions in the three courts-martial in Baghdad. NPR's Emily Harris reports.
  • The debate within the Catholic Church over politicians who disagree with church policy -- specifically, the church's opposition to abortion -- could have an affect on the campaign of Sen. John Kerry, a pro-choice Catholic and the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee. Hear NPR's Liane Hansen and Peter Steinfels, a religion and ethics columnist for The New York Times and author of A People Adrift: The Crisis of the Roman Catholic Church in America.
  • The body of American hostage Paul Johnson is found in Saudi Arabia. Militant Islamists claiming ties to al Qaeda said they were responsible for beheading the Lockheed Martin worker, who was taken captive Saturday. President Bush denounces Johnson's killers as "barbaric." Hear an NPR News report.
  • Russian President Vladimir Putin says that after Sept.11, but before the war in Iraq, Russia gave the Bush administration intelligence suggesting Saddam Hussein planned terrorist attacks on U.S. territory. Putin's surprise statement comes as the Bush administration defends its assertion that Saddam had ties to terrorist groups. Hear NPR's Steve Inskeep and NPR's Lawrence Sheets.
  • In a 5-4 vote with vast repercussions for the U.S. criminal justice system, the Supreme Court invalidates the criminal sentencing system of Washington state. The court's ruling emphasizes the role of juries in determining sentences, and stirs speculation that the sentencing guidelines used by many states and the federal government won't be able to withstand a constitutional challenge. NPR's Nina Totenberg reports.
  • The chief of security for Iraq's northern oil fields was assassinated Wednesday, and bombings of Iraq's pipelines have all but shut down Iraq's oil exports. NPR's Emily Harris reports from Baghdad about the latest developments in Iraq.
  • The judge in the civil rights cases of four former police officers in the killing of George Floyd said that he has accepted Derek Chauvin's plea agreement and will sentence him to 20 to 25 years.
  • Saudi officials say militants suspected to have links to al Qaeda killed 22 people before government commandos flushed them out of an upscale housing complex in an early-morning raid. The raid, launched from helicopters, ended a standoff stemming from Saturday's attacks on foreigners working in Khobar oil offices. Hear NPR's Linda Wertheimer and Global Radio News reporter Nigel Perry.
  • Two U.S. soldiers and several dozen Iraqi militiamen are dead after overnight gun battles in the Iraqi city of Kufa. The continuing fighting in Kufa and in the nearby city of Najaf threaten last week's truce between the U.S. military and radical Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr. NPR's Eric Westervelt reports.