95.3 / 88.5 FM Grand Rapids and 95.3 FM Muskegon
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Cinematographer Greg Toland

Ways To Subscribe

First aired September, 2026


David Hast and WGVU’s Scott Vander Werf talk about three movies that cinematographer Greg Toland worked on, including The Grapes of Wrath, all of which informed the artistry of the masterpiece, Citizen Kane.

David Hast: Scott, have you seen The Grapes of Wrath?

Scott Vander Werf: I've seen John Ford's version of The Grapes of Wrath from 1940 many times over the years. That was one of the films that we studied a lot in different classes in film school. And then, of course, just as somebody who loves John Steinbeck's book and then, of course, John Ford, I've watched it since those days. I've probably seen it maybe a dozen times or more.

DH: Not surprising. It is a great American masterpiece of Hollywood cinema about the struggles of Oklahoma farmers during the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression. I just mention it today because we're going to talk about Greg Toland, who was the cinematographer on the Grapes of Wrath. Toland is widely regarded as one of the greatest cinematographers in Hollywood history, and he is especially known for being the cinematographer on the movie Citizen Kane, the movie that in many ways changed everything for movies, for Hollywood movies anyway. In the Grapes of Wrath, we see Toland trying out certain techniques, compositions, camera and lighting techniques, and certain photographic technology that would be fully realized by the time they made Citizen Kane.These things, the things that Citizen Kane is known for are these wide-angled, deep-focus, shots where you have depth of field where things are in focus from the close foreground all the way to infinity in the background. A lot of use of dark, darkness, and shadow, the use of single source and non-direct lighting.And to do this, there were a lot of technologies they had to develop. Faster, sharper lenses, wide angle lenses, and faster film. By faster, I mean film that could absorb light faster. So you could shoot in low light and still be able to have a wide range of focus. This way of shooting movies is, totally widespread, it's so widespread nowadays that it's lost its sense of newness. When I was a teacher, I would show a movie like Citizen Kane to students and they'd be like, “so what?”Toland at this time, I this was a very important time in the late 30s, early 40s in terms of developing a whole new visual style that lives on strongly and is used all the time now. Because before that, at that time, movie stars were almost always, if you looked at movies from the 30s, the stars are always shot in a bright, flat light to make them look glamorous.And Toland and a number of other cinematographers at that time were kind of opposed to that. They were really deliberately and meticulously kind of deconstructing the look of Hollywood glamor and rejecting the bright lighting on the stars' faces and going for a kind of harsher, more contrasty aesthetic. And we can see this, everyone, the movie you're gonna cite is Citizen Kane, which gave way to a lot of uses of these kind of techniques. But if you look at Greg Toland's work, especially in a few films we're looking at today, you can see him getting there. So the movies we're gonna look at are a movie called Dead End from 1937, The Grapes of Wrath, and the one he did, literally two months before Citizen Kane, the long voyage home.

SVW: And you you mentioned how your students would be like, so what? But and also talking about the cinematographers wanting to get away from the sort of glamour aesthetic, but also just in terms of pure storytelling, you know, this is a way of making the storytelling even more deeper and more, you know, bringing the viewer into the world of the movie too.

DH: Well, that's kind of the point about movies, is that you get meaning and you get the story not just from the script and the performances, which you can make a strong case, those are the primary things. You gotta have a great story and then you need really good performances. But a lot of the meaning comes from the way you use the technique. It's visual, the story is told visually. You watch movies or TV series and...sometimes you'll see scenes go on for minutes and minutes without a line of dialogue. They're telling the story visually. Let's look at the three films. Have you seen Dead End?

SVW: I saw Dead End, 1937.This was the first time that I'd ever seen Dead End, and I really enjoyed it. And I can tell, I see what you mean in terms of how Greg Toland was working on these techniques that were really fully realized with Citizen Kane.

DH: Yeah, Dead End is this 1937 film starring Joel McCrae and Sylvia Sidney, wonderful actors at that time. Humphrey Bogart, before he became a big star, but in his typical role as an evil gangster. He's great.It was the second of six films that Greg Toland, the cinematographer, did with the director William Wyler.And five out of those six films are all really great. Dead End, Wuthering Heights, The Westerner, a western with Gary Cooper, The Little Foxes and the best years of our lives and Weiler did some of his best work in those. And in this film you can see it he's trying out these techniques even though he doesn't quite have the technology yet. So most of it shot on this single large set although there's some shots that are supposed to happen down alleys and things where they there you could tell they're doing it in another studio and it's like they can get an effect just in you know some close up stuff. So he's trying these kind of things where, you know, like he's got things in the foreground all the way to the background. He's trying to get all this depth so you can play the action out in one shot without a lot of editing. But he can't, doesn't quite have the technology yet to have it all be in focus and to be able to hold that for a long time.

SVW: And within this tenement area,there are, there constantly is the movement of people in the background too. And you can see that he wants them all to be in focus completely. They're not quite there, like you said.

DH: Yeah. So and of course, you know, the director is is credit. It has gets credit for this, too. It's not just great. It's not Greg Toland's movie, but Toland's style was good for it. That's 1937.Remember, Citizen Kane is 1941. So, the two movies that two movies that came right before it, The Grapes of Wrath, was like three movies before Citizen Kane. And so that's 1940. And by then, he's got most of the technology. So, we mostly think of Grapes of Wrath, people who've seen it. You almost always think of it as, it has this look of like the Depression era photography of the Dust Bowl farmers, the photography of Dorothea Lange and Walker Evans. But there's also a bunch of like night scenes and dark interiors.

SVW: And these are some of the most memorable scenes in the movie too.

DH: Yeah and he's doing these things that they really didn't do in Holly like let's make the scene look like it's just shot by one candle or one match you know which they actually couldn't even do yet then they didn't have fast enough film they would the guy would strike the match and a light would come on and they were so good at it you didn't notice that that's what was happening and he does do a lot of this wide-angle deep focus stuff so for example you see a shot of the farmlands where the poor people are and the camera will be set you know, maybe down low. So right in the foreground is dirt and then the people in the mid ground and then you see all the way to the landscape and the sky all the way in the background and it's all in focus.

SVW: And also the way that he has the journey of the family and how he films the surrounding landscape in that way as well.

DH: Yeah, and faces, right? He does these things. You know, again, we're saying look back at classic Hollywood from earlier period and the stars are always brightly lit and the key lights on them. He does scenes where there's close-ups of people. There's either just one light kind of maybe going across their eyes or a slash across their face or the light might not even be on their face. He's now for the first time really for Hollywood experimenting by, we're not even going to see their face very well, but there's a bright light kind of going across their shoulder or somewhere in the background.Again, you see this all the time now, but this is where it started.

SVW: And in terms of this film, it just emphasizes the trauma that all the characters are going through.

DH: Yes. So, Grapes of Wrath, great movie, shot by Greg Toland, John Ford directed. And then John Ford did another film with Greg Toland. Literally, I looked it up. It's called The Long Voyage Home. It's a movie about sailors. Merchant Marines

SVW: During World War two

DH: during World War two. So there's some involvement of the war in the plot. It's an early starring role for John Wayne. He'd already done stagecoach the year before but and also the great character actor Thomas Mitchell is in it.

SVW: Ward Bond

DH: Ward Bond is in it. Who's also in dead end. He says a very small role. He's the doorman in that. And he's in a ton of John Ford. Look up Ward Bond and IMDB. The guy was probably in 300 movies. He was just as workman-like character actor. They shot this movie in April 1940, I looked it up, and Citizen Kane began shooting in June 1940. So there's no doubt this is the movie that Greg Toland worked on right before Citizen Kane. And it's interesting that it's John Ford, right, because the director of Citizen Kane, Orson Welles, famously worshiped John Ford. Didn't you say he...

SVW: Well, mean, this is an earlier film, but he watched Stagecoach like 50 times.

DH: Right, right. So Stagecoach is 39, Long Voyage Home is 40. I'm sure he'd seen that too. I'm sure. Absolutely. Because he's working with Greg Toland. And in fact, you know, here's a funny little bit of trivia. One of the things that's famous about Citizen Kane, people cite it to say, well, yes, it's such an amazing groundbreaking film. And one of the most important things is the cinematography. And that's even shown by the fact that when you see the opening titles, Orson Welles put his name, “directed by Orson Welles,” on the same title card as “Greg Toland's cinematographer.” They're listed together. Did you happen to notice in the Long Voyage Home that John Ford did the same thing?

SVW: I did not notice that.

DH: Yes. And I don't think I've ever, I can't ever recall seeing, you see directed by John Ford, it's the last thing you see. This had directed by John Ford, photography by Greg Toland on the screen at the same time, right before Citizen Kane, so…I personally am not a huge fan of it as a movie,it's undoubtedly got all the techniques down.

SVW: But you like it, don't you?

DH: Yeah, I like it.

SVW: I mean, it's, you know, men on a merchant marine,rusted hulk of a ship, crossing the Atlantic, carrying a cargo of weaponry for the war, and they're being threatened when the closer they get, they get to Europe with by Nazi subs…I mean, come on.

DH: Right. And it's character studies, right? So most of the movie, these guys are just drunk and fighting, right?

SVW: Yeah, most of it. In fact, the war in the sense the war is kind of in even though it's it hovers over the plot. These men, they just want to they just want the voyage to end so they can get paid and and go get drunk. But and some of them know they're going to continue on as sailors and merchant marines, but there's a big focus on the on getting the John Wayne character who's a young guy who hasn't been home in 10 years to get him to go back to Sweden where he's from to visit his family.

DH: Yeah. And there's another good to like with it. John Wayne has the worst fake Swedish accent you've ever heard.

SVW: Well that's the one thing in the movie that I didn't pick up on until the very end when he's talking to the woman in the in the tavern and he said he's mentioning how long you know that he's from Sweden and he and I didn't realize that. It didn't sound like a Swedish accent.

DH: Not at all.They just told him to speak with bad grammar, say things like, “me go home now.”And John Quaylen's in this, is one of the most famous actors in The Grapes of Wrath. In Grapes of Wrath, he plays a poor farmer but usually, John Quaylen almost always played someone with a Swedish accent. He's in this doing a... and he is convincingly sound Swedish. He has the Swedish accent in The Searchers and next to John Wayne, John Wayne sounds ridiculous, but anyway, that's not what we're talking about.Again, this movie, what are we talking about here? We're talking about stuff that, yes, there was some kind of use of, talk about German Expressionism in the silent era, certainly shot with shadow and light in similar ways, but they definitely didn't have the advanced technology. You can see the influence here. You can anticipate the influence that Toland cinematography had on Film Noir coming up, which starts really right after, it starts in the early 40s, even though Greg Toland himself never shot anything you'd call a Film Noir. Once again, we see this, and by this point, he's got it made. They worked on this technology.mean, obviously, Toland must have worked with lens companies, but in some of it, they could make right in the studio workshops.These studios had a lot of stuff. And you can see at this point, he's got the technology and you really can you picture some of the shots in the movie that are...?

SVW: Yeah. The shots when you're there at one end of the ship and there's things happening all along what you can see on the deck. And everything's in focus from the very end of the shot right up to the beginning of the shot and things are happening in terms of water waves turbulence and,or, or the sequences where the crew members are drunk and they're just careening all over the place and they're at different parts of the screen.

DH: Yeah. And the important thing about this is it allows you a director to often do a shot where a lot happens and they don't have to edit. They don't have to edit to show, here's the water splashing on the deck and here's the character falling when the ship sways. You know, you're not going to do it if some of that's out of focus. So you use multiple shots in edit and the style of non-editing that which was kind of like what Citizen Kane was made of lends a certain kind of realism that is pretty powerful. Yeah, one shot in there…I really like the shots towards the end of the movie when they get when they finally arrive in England and they're in this neighborhood and there they get to use like a regular studio set instead of the boat set. Now they get to use a street set.

SVW: Essentially cobbled streets with with brick housing right alleyways.

DH: And just like when we talked about how they had the wet cobblestones and the third man when we talked about The Third Man a couple shows ago same thing is these cobblestones which are wet and so I can remember one shot where like you know, It's set the camera set pretty low and so you see these very sharply focused wet cobblestones of the street in the foreground and then all the way back like down two blocks and a character runs from the background of the foreground right into a lot, know,where he's lit in his face and he's very close up. So you're seeing this, it's a kind of thing, you know, we could name endless examples, but for instance, when Sergio Leone, the way Sergio Leone would work with these very tight closeups on faces, but then you see the whole Western landscape behind them that's using these similar techniques.

SVW: And one of the things in terms of Greg Toland is that he did not, he died young. So we experience his artistry in a succession of films and then that artistry stops.

DH: He died like from cerebral hemorrhage or something when he was 44,46 in the late 1940s. You could ask yourself what would he have done? What other kinds of interesting movies would he have been a cinematographer? But he'd made his mark because by then many, many other cinematographers were influenced by him. And it's not like he's the only person who was doing these kind of things. People like James Wong Howe were coming up with these ideas on their own too. But he made these certain major breakthroughs that, really it was, was Toland.

SVW: And for me as a young viewer, when I first saw Citizen Kane, when I was a teenager and I was so impressed with it, it was Greg Toland's artistry that really informed that experience for myself.

DH: Yeah. And the way he perfectly matched up with Orson Welles artistry.

SVW: Alright, well thanks for joining us.

DH: Thanks, Scott.

David Hast is a retired high school English teacher. He has an MFA in Radio/TV/Film from Northwestern University and worked 15 years in the film and video industry. Some years ago he taught video production part-time at GVSU, and as a high school teacher he regularly taught a course in Film and Media Analysis.
Related Content